The confusion here seems to be mistaking vice (and an expansive understanding of vice, at that) with genuine evil. Vice has to do with weakness; evil has to do with injustice. The Teen Mania obsession with SD&RR winds up declaring "war" on weakness while ignoring injustice. That's not good. Nor is it compatible with Christianity.
The always brilliant Fred Clark from a resurfaced post from 2006.
You could take out "Teen Mania" and "SD&RR" and replace them with the "Republican party", "mainstream American evangelicals" or the "Religious Right".
Abscence of vice is not what denotes a Christian. That's Grace. From God to the Christian and from the Christian to the world around him/her.